Rights

Knowing Your Rights: What to do During a Police Encounter

March 21, 2026 by Yuliya Kelmansky in Rights  
Thumbnail for: Knowing Your Rights: What to do During a Police Encounter

It Can Happen To Anyone, Anytime

Police encounters can happen anytime, anywhere—often when you least expect them. For that reason, it’s crucial to understand your rights as a citizen when interacting with law enforcement. In this article, we’ll break down 10 essential rules for handling encounters with the police.

  1. Don’t get angry. Always keep your cool and be calm.
  2. Don’t tell them that you know your rights, acting naive is usually best.
  3. Don’t answer trick questions like “Do you know why I stopped you?”, you DO NOT know.
  4. Don’t agree to a search, EVER.
  5. Don’t just wait, ask “am I free to go?”
  6. Don’t get tricked by threats, cops can and do lie.
  7. Don’t admit anything. Remain silent instead.
  8. Don’t let them in without a warrant.
  9. Don’t Be Rude or Uncooperative.
  10. Don’t answer questions without a lawyer, their misconduct can always be challenged in court.

1. Don’t Get Angry

Generally speaking, no one likes an obnoxious, irrational person. Cops are no different. De-escalation is the primary objective. So, be a rational human being doing everyday, rational things. You’re busy and you need to get back to what you were doing.

2. Don’t tell them that you know your rights

When you’re a ‘smartass’, you’re provoking the officers. In their lens, it feels like you are trying to disparage them. Don’t do this. Everyone is on the same level here. Be respectful. The only thing you need to tell them is that you are busy and would like to be on your way.

3. Don’t fall for trick questions

The police will ask loaded questions in an attempt to fish information out of you. It’s best to recognize these types of questions, and answer with a simple “I don’t know” or equivalent. For example, they may ask “Do you know why I pulled you over?”. If you answer “Because I was speeding?”, you essentially just admitted to speeding whether you were or not. The correct answer is “I don’t know, officer”.

4. Don’t ever agree to a search

The police have no right to search unless there is something illegal that they can see, smell or hear. This is called probable cause. If they don’t have probable cause, then they must obtain a warrant to search. NEVER EVER agree to a search. In fact, say it clearly “I do not agree to a search”.

5. Don’t just wait

You were busy with errands, work, whatever you were doing before being stopped. You have deadlines to meet and appointments to get to. Let the officer know that you need to be on your way by saying something like “Am I free to go Sir?”. Always show respect and be rational when asking the questions.

6. Don’t get Tricked by Threats

The police can and will lie to you to get you to admit guilt. Don’t do it. An aggressive officer may get angry that none of his tactics are working that allows him to violate your rights. Just sit there calmly and silently if the officer begins to yell threats to you. Keep telling him you would like to be on your way.

7. Don’t Admit Anything, Remain Silent

In the event that they are placing you under arrest, it is best to remain silent at this point. Anything you say can and will be twisted around to make a case AGAINST you in the report. They will never make a report that helps your case, or proves your innocence because that would make writing the report pointless in the first place. Just be quiet and comply with the officers.

8. Don’t Let Them in Without a Warrant

As you have already stated that you do not agree to a search, do your best to not allow the police to enter your car, house, pockets, backpack or anything that you own without a warrant. Warrants are not easy to obtain and must be given in writing by a judge.

9. Don’t Be Rude or Uncooperative

As an upstanding Citizen, be as nice and respectful as possible. There is literally no reason to treat the cops rudely and it will always end up making things worse.

10. Don’t Answer Questions Without a Lawyer

If you find yourself being arrested, clearly state to the police officers that you don’t want to answer any questions without a lawyer. Make sure that you get 3 phone calls and assume that the calls are recorded. Call your attorney immediately, or family/friends that will contact one for you.

Free Consultation

If you have recently been arrested, please don’t hesitate to call us for a free, no-obligation consultation with Yuliya Kelmansky. During your call, Kelmansky will hear the details of the case and advise you on the best approach to defend yourself. If you wish, a consultation in our office can be promptly scheduled.

Call Us for a FREE Case Review: 213-932-8922

Yuliya Kelmansky is an Expert in Criminal Law who has over 10 years of practice defending a variety of criminal cases.

Read our Client Reviews

Second Part of the Series:

For Part 2, please visit the article:

KNOWING YOUR RIGHTS: WHAT TO DO IF YOU ARE BEING ARRESTED

References:

[1] ACLU Know Your Rights: Police Interactions

Reputation is Everything

  • five-star reviewVery well, spoken, organized, reaches deep into the facts, sensitive to a clients needs and is not shaken by her opposition. Knows how to stand up for her client. I would go to battle with her any day as co-counsel.- Charles F.

  • five-star reviewI had a case where a friend accused me of things I did not do. The accusations were untrue but I was charged. Within a couple weeks my case was dropped. Very thankful to Yuliya! Recommend.- Alexander M.

  • five-star reviewJulia is a great and attentive attorney. We needed to expunge my husband’s DUI case that took place 15 years ago and Julia helped us to get it done within no time. Highly recommend her services to anyone who is looking for a criminal law attorney!- Karina S.

  • five-star reviewI’m so grateful for the services that were provided by Yuliya. Her experience, kindness, and thoroughness during this difficult time went above and beyond. Yuliya was there for every court date and explained to me every step. I highly recommend her.- Alexandr S.

Free Consultation

    Contact Us Form