Criminal Defense

What Is a Motion Hearing in a Criminal Case?

November 19, 2026 by Anastasiia Ponomarova in Criminal Defense  Legal Resources  
Thumbnail for: What Is a Motion Hearing in a Criminal Case?

What is a motion hearing?

A motion hearing is a court proceeding where a judge reviews one or more formal requests from the prosecution or defense. A motion is a written request that an attorney submits to ask the court to take a specific action. During the hearing, both sides explain why the judge should approve or deny that request. Motion hearings take place in civil and criminal cases. They can happen before trial, during trial, or after a verdict.

Who takes part in a motion hearing?

The main participants include the judge and attorneys for both sides. Witnesses may also take part in some hearings. The judge reviews the evidence, listens to arguments, and asks questions. Clients and defendants usually do not speak during the hearing. However, the judge’s decision can directly affect their interests. Courts may hold these hearings in person or online, depending on local rules.

Types of motion hearings

Courts generally classify motion hearings as evidentiary or non-evidentiary. A non-evidentiary hearing involves only legal arguments from each attorney. An evidentiary hearing may include witness testimony and documents, much like a trial. However, filing a motion does not always lead to a hearing. In California and other jurisdictions, a judge may decide a motion by reviewing written documents and legal briefs. In these cases, the parties do not need to appear in court.

How does a judge handle a motion hearing?

The hearing follows a clear order. First, the party who filed the motion, called the movant, presents their arguments. They refer to relevant laws, statutes, and court decisions. The other party then responds. The movant may also give a short reply before the judge ends the arguments.

After hearing both sides, the judge may issue a ruling right away or review the matter before making a decision later. The court then issues a formal order and adds it to the case record. This order guides the next steps in the case. If the judge grants the motion, the court approves the request. If the judge denies it, the case continues without the requested action.

What motions can lead to a motion hearing?

Several types of pretrial and trial motions can lead to a motion hearing. Each motion has its own rules and legal standards. The judge reviews the request and listens to arguments from both sides.

Motion to dismiss

A motion to dismiss asks the court to end one or more claims, or an entire case, before it moves forward. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b), reasons for dismissal include lack of subject-matter jurisdiction, lack of personal jurisdiction, improper venue, and insufficient service of process. A defendant may also argue that the complaint fails to state a valid legal claim.

The defendant usually files this motion shortly after the plaintiff serves the complaint. A dismissal "with prejudice" permanently ends the case. A dismissal "without prejudice" allows the plaintiff to file the case again.

Motion to compel discovery

A motion to compel discovery asks the court to require one party to answer a proper discovery request. A party may file this motion when the other side fails to provide the requested information. Under FRCP Rule 37, the moving party must first make a good faith effort to resolve the issue without court involvement.

The motion must identify the disputed requests, the other party’s objections, and the reasons for the requested order. If the judge grants the motion, the court may also require the non-complying party to pay the movant’s reasonable attorney’s fees.

Motion for summary judgment

A motion for summary judgment asks the court to decide one or more claims without a trial. Under FRCP Rule 56, the movant must show that no genuine dispute exists over a material fact. The movant must also show that the opposing party cannot win, even if the court accepts all its allegations as true.

The court may grant summary judgment on the entire case or only certain claims or defenses. The other party must receive notice and a fair chance to respond before the judge makes a decision.

Motion to suppress evidence

A motion to suppress asks a criminal court to exclude evidence that police obtained in violation of a defendant’s constitutional rights. This motion relies on the Fourth Amendment’s exclusionary rule. It often challenges evidence from an unlawful search or seizure.

In federal courts, Rule 41(h) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure governs these motions. The moving party must show why the court should exclude the evidence. In California and other jurisdictions, defendants must file these motions before trial if they can reasonably raise the issue at that time.

How is a motion hearing scheduled?

Courts follow local rules when scheduling motion hearings. However, most courts use a similar process. First, the filing party must submit a written motion. The party then contacts the court clerk or, in some jurisdictions, the bailiff to request an available date on the court’s motion calendar.

Filing the motion and notice of hearing

At filing, the attorney selects a date and submits a formal notice of hearing. This notice must include the case name, case number, type of motion, and hearing date, time, and location.

The filing party must also notify the opposing party before the hearing. The deadline depends on the jurisdiction. Some courts require as few as three court days of notice, while others require at least 14 days. Parties may deliver notice in person, by first-class mail, by email, or through an electronic court filing system.

Court calendars and hearing times

Courts organize motion hearings into specific calendars, also called dockets. Some courts use separate calendars based on the expected length of each hearing. For example, the Virginia Beach Circuit Court uses a Friday Motion Docket for matters that take no more than 30 minutes. It also uses a Duty Judge Docket for longer hearings or matters that need more briefing.

Similarly, Norfolk Circuit Court schedules motions in 30-minute blocks between 9:00 a.m. and 11:00 a.m. on weekdays. Attorneys must coordinate longer hearings with a docket clerk.

Online scheduling and special hearings

Many courts now use online systems to schedule motion hearings. Parties can check available dates, coordinate with opposing counsel, and submit a hearing request by email or through an e-filing portal. Some courts also allow remote hearings through platforms such as Zoom or WebEx. However, parties usually need the assigned judge’s approval in advance. They must also submit their request in writing.

Some motions, such as motions to suppress evidence, may require more notice than standard motions. Courts may also set a specific date for these hearings. Emergency hearings follow separate rules. A party must show good cause, and the court generally schedules the hearing outside its regular motion calendar.

How do you prepare for a motion hearing?

Preparing for a motion hearing involves several steps. You must follow court rules, meet deadlines, and gather the documents and evidence that support your request.

Check court rules, deadlines, and any tentative ruling

Court rules set deadlines for filing motions and limits on oral arguments. In California, most civil courts post a tentative ruling by 3:00 p.m. on the court day before the hearing.

If a party disagrees with the tentative ruling and wants to present oral arguments, that party must notify the court and all other parties by 4:00 p.m. that day. If neither side gives notice, the tentative ruling becomes final, and the court cancels the hearing. Judges rarely change tentative rulings. Therefore, parties should consider whether oral arguments will help their case.

File and serve the required papers

You must file every motion, plea, or application in writing with the court clerk. You must also serve copies on all other parties. In federal court, attorneys generally file documents electronically through an ECF system unless the judge orders otherwise.

Paper filings must include an original and one copy for the judge. You must serve and file opposition papers at least nine court days before the hearing. A reply to the opposition must follow at least five court days before the hearing. Each filing must include a certificate of service to confirm that you delivered copies to all opposing parties.

Prepare your arguments and supporting evidence

Organize all the evidence you plan to present. This may include testimony from witnesses with first-hand knowledge. You may also need photographs, emails, text messages, and certified public records.

Prepare each exhibit in the proper format. Make enough copies for the opposing party, the judge, and your own records. Good preparation helps you present a clear and convincing argument in court.

What happens during a motion hearing?

Before the hearing, the judge usually reviews the motion papers and any legal briefs. This review helps guide the oral arguments. Attorneys do not need to repeat everything in their written filings. Instead, they focus on key legal issues, answer the judge’s questions, and explain their positions.

Oral arguments from both sides

The movant speaks first and explains the legal reasons for the motion. The attorney may cite relevant statutes, court rules, and case law. The opposing party then presents a response.

During the arguments, both sides may agree on certain facts or smaller issues. These agreements narrow the disputes and help the judge understand which issues still need a decision.

When does the court hear oral arguments?

Not every motion hearing includes oral arguments. Courts often decide discovery and calendar motions based on the written papers. However, the court may order oral arguments with at least two days’ notice. It may also approve a party’s request.

For major motions, parties generally have the right to oral arguments when they properly request them in the moving papers, opposition papers, or reply. A party may also make the request only if the other side contests the motion.

Witness testimony and other evidence

Sometimes, a motion involves facts that do not appear in the official case record. In these cases, the court may review affidavits or require the person who signed an affidavit to answer questions under cross-examination. The judge may also hear witness testimony or review depositions.

The judge may also order the attorneys to present arguments by telephone conference. The court must keep a complete record of all arguments and rulings during that conference.

If a party withdraws a motion or settles the matter before the hearing, the parties must promptly notify the court.

What happens after the judge rules on a motion?

After the hearing, the judge may announce the decision in court or issue a written ruling later. In New York, the law gives a judge 60 days to decide a motion if the judge does not rule immediately. The decision takes legal effect only after the court clerk enters it and adds the official date.

Notice of Entry and court orders

After the court enters the order, the winning party must serve a Notice of Entry on the losing party. The notice must include a copy of the signed order. The winning party must also file proof of service with the court clerk. This notice starts the deadline for the opposing party to file an appeal.

In California, the party responsible for preparing the proposed order must serve it on the other party within 10 calendar days of the hearing. The opposing party then has 20 calendar days to approve the order or submit objections. If the opposing party does not respond, the party who prepared the order submits it to the court without approval within 25 calendar days of the hearing.

Appealing the judge’s decision

A party who disagrees with the ruling may appeal based on a legal or factual error. However, the party must file the appeal within the applicable deadline. An appeal does not automatically stop the court from enforcing its order. To pause enforcement during the appeal, the party must file a separate Motion to Stay and obtain the court’s approval.

Need a Lawyer?

If you are facing a motion hearing, an experienced criminal defense attorney can help protect your rights and present strong legal arguments. Contact a qualified attorney to review your case, explain your options, and guide you through the court process.

RELATED ARTICLE:

Theft Attorney - Call 213-932-8922
 (Click to Enlarge)

Call 213-932-8922, for a free consultation.

Reputation is Everything

› ‹
  • five-star reviewVery well, spoken, organized, reaches deep into the facts, sensitive to a clients needs and is not shaken by her opposition. Knows how to stand up for her client. I would go to battle with her any day as co-counsel.- Charles F.

  • five-star reviewI had a case where a friend accused me of things I did not do. The accusations were untrue but I was charged. Within a couple weeks my case was dropped. Very thankful to Yuliya! Recommend.- Alexander M.

  • five-star reviewJulia is a great and attentive attorney. We needed to expunge my husband’s DUI case that took place 15 years ago and Julia helped us to get it done within no time. Highly recommend her services to anyone who is looking for a criminal law attorney!- Karina S.

  • five-star reviewI’m so grateful for the services that were provided by Yuliya. Her experience, kindness, and thoroughness during this difficult time went above and beyond. Yuliya was there for every court date and explained to me every step. I highly recommend her.- Alexandr S.

Free Consultation

    Contact Us Form