Criminal Defense

What Is a Pretrial Hearing? What Happens Before a Criminal Trial?

November 06, 2026 by Anastasiia Ponomarova in Criminal Defense  Legal Resources  
Thumbnail for: What Is a Pretrial Hearing? What Happens Before a Criminal Trial?

What Happens at a Pretrial Hearing in California? Your Complete Guide

A pretrial hearing can decide whether your California case goes to trial, gets dismissed, or ends with a plea deal. If you face criminal charges, understanding this stage is important for building a strong defense. You should know how discovery works, what settlement talks may offer, and how pretrial motions can affect your case. This guide explains each stage, from arraignment through preliminary hearings. It also explains what to expect and how to prepare with your attorney.

What Is a Pretrial Hearing in California?

After arraignment, the case enters the pretrial period. This stage can shape what happens next in your case.

Where pretrial hearings fit after arraignment

After arraignment, the judge sets more court dates. The next date is usually a pretrial conference for misdemeanors or a preliminary hearing for felonies. The pretrial process starts when you enter a not guilty plea at arraignment. However, a pretrial hearing does not mean your trial comes next. It refers to any hearing after arraignment and before trial. Depending on the charges and settlement talks, this stage can last from a few days to more than a year.

Who attends and what the judge does

The prosecution, defense, and judge attend a pretrial hearing. However, no jury takes part. During these hearings, the parties may:

  • Set deadlines for documents, future hearings, and the trial
  • Challenge evidence, such as material from an illegal search
  • Update the court on trial preparation
  • File a motion for discovery
  • Negotiate a plea deal
  • Agree on facts that can narrow the issues for trial
  • Discuss witness availability

The judge may also join settlement talks between the lawyers. This can help both sides work toward an agreement.

How misdemeanor and felony cases differ

Misdemeanor cases do not have preliminary hearings. Instead, the court often schedules a Trial Readiness Conference. During this meeting, attorneys exchange discovery and discuss a possible settlement before setting a trial date. Felony cases follow a different process. The court usually schedules a Felony Settlement Conference first. If the attorneys cannot reach an agreement, the court sets a preliminary hearing date. In felony cases, the preliminary hearing may be your first chance to testify in court. No earlier evidentiary hearing takes place.

When you must appear and when your lawyer may appear for you

The court will tell you if you must attend a pretrial hearing in person. Missing a required appearance can have serious consequences. The court may impose sanctions, add criminal charges, or issue an arrest warrant. Attendance rules vary by hearing type and county. Before each court date, ask your attorney what the court expects. Do not assume your lawyer can appear for you.

What to review with your lawyer before court

Reviewing your case with your lawyer before court can help you avoid problems. Go over police reports and any plea offers before the hearing. Do not wait until you reach the courthouse to discuss them. You should also understand any promises or future court dates that may come from the hearing. Missing a later court date can create more problems. Good preparation helps you avoid surprises. It also gives you a clearer idea of your options when the judge asks for an update.

Discovery: How Both Sides Share Evidence

Before a case goes to trial, both sides need to know what evidence exists. Discovery is the formal process that allows the prosecution and defense to exchange evidence. Its main purpose is to prevent surprises at trial. California follows this process under Penal Code Sections 1054 through 1054.10. Voters approved Proposition 115, which led to these rules. Unlike civil cases, criminal discovery in California follows strict deadlines. These rules help courts manage trials while protecting constitutional rights.

Police reports, witness statements, and other evidence

Both sides must share their evidence at least 30 days before trial. This duty continues after the deadline. If new evidence appears, such as a lab result or witness update, both sides must share it right away. The prosecution must provide police reports, arrest logs, and dispatch records. It must also share the names, addresses, and statements of planned witnesses. This includes 911 calls, body camera footage, and dashcam videos. Physical evidence also falls under these rules. Examples include DNA results, ballistics reports, and fingerprint analysis. If the prosecutor plans to call an expert witness, the defense must receive that expert’s written report and qualifications.

The prosecutor’s duty to share evidence that could help the defense

Prosecutors also have a constitutional duty under Brady v. Maryland. This rule requires them to share evidence that favors the accused on guilt or punishment. They must do this even if the defense does not ask. Such evidence may point to another suspect or show that a witness gave different statements. It may also reveal facts that affect a witness’s credibility. For example, a pending plea deal or criminal charge against a witness may qualify as Giglio material. Prosecutors must also disclose felony convictions that may affect a witness’s credibility. If the state fails to share this evidence, the court may impose sanctions, declare a mistrial, or dismiss the charges.

Defense disclosure duties and limits on sharing witness details

The Fifth Amendment protects defendants from self-incrimination. As a result, the defense has fewer disclosure duties than the prosecution. If the defense plans to call witnesses other than the defendant, it must share their names, addresses, and recorded statements. It must also provide expert reports and physical evidence that it plans to use at trial. However, the defense does not have to disclose evidence that incriminates the defendant. It also does not have to share its legal strategy, private attorney-client communications, or details about witnesses it will not call. Privacy rules also protect victims and witnesses. Defense attorneys cannot give defendants unredacted contact information for these individuals. However, attorneys can review the discovery with their clients to confirm the facts.

Settlement Talks: Can the Case End Without Trial?

Not every case that enters the pretrial stage goes before a jury. In fact, most California criminal cases end through negotiations before trial begins.

How pretrial conferences help both sides discuss a deal

A pretrial conference, sometimes called a settlement conference, gives the prosecutor and defense attorney time to discuss a possible deal. Most counties schedule this meeting about four to six weeks after arraignment. However, local court schedules can affect the timing. By this stage, the prosecutor has usually shared police reports and other discovery. This gives both sides a chance to discuss the actual evidence. The numbers show how common these agreements are. In San Mateo County, about 95.5% of cases end through plea bargaining. Only 0.5% go to trial, while about 4% get dismissed. Across California, plea bargains resolve more than 90% of criminal cases. These negotiations can also move quickly. One county reported that each misdemeanor plea bargain took about six minutes during scheduled sessions.

What a plea offer may include

A plea offer usually asks the defendant to plead guilty or no contest. In return, the prosecution offers some benefit. This may include reduced charges, dismissed counts, a specific sentencing recommendation, or an agreement to leave out certain facts that could increase the sentence. Charge bargaining reduces the severity of the offense. Sentence bargaining keeps the charge but seeks a lower punishment. Fact bargaining limits which details the court considers. In some cases, a plea deal can reduce the possible punishment by as much as three-quarters compared to a trial outcome. Some counties also allow several rounds of talks in felony cases. Offers may change as new information becomes available.

Why accepting or rejecting an offer is the defendant’s choice

The defense attorney must tell the client about every offer from the prosecutor. However, only the defendant can accept or reject it. No attorney can make this decision for someone else. You should never feel rushed into signing a plea agreement. If you reject an offer, negotiations may continue. The prosecution may make another offer, or the case may move toward trial. Even when both sides agree, the judge can reject a plea deal. This may happen if the agreement does not follow the law or serve the public interest.

Questions to ask about sentencing and other plea consequences

Before signing a plea agreement, ask your attorney these important questions:

  • Does this plea waive your right to appeal?
  • Will the conviction affect your immigration status, gun rights, or professional license?
  • Does the charge count as a strike under California’s Three Strikes law?
  • What happens if you violate a probation condition later?
  • Can you ever expunge the record, and what limits will remain?

A no contest plea does not directly admit guilt. It may also help in related civil matters. However, courts generally treat it like a guilty plea in criminal and immigration cases.

Pretrial Motions: What Can the Judge Decide?

Either side in a California criminal case can ask the judge to decide a legal issue before trial. These requests are called motions. A motion can affect which evidence the court allows, whether charges remain, or whether the case moves forward. The judge decides the outcome of each motion. These decisions can change the strength of either side’s case before a jury gets involved.

Motions to suppress evidence from an unlawful search

A motion to suppress under Penal Code 1538.5 asks the court to exclude evidence from an illegal search or seizure. The Fourth Amendment protects people against unreasonable searches. If officers search without a warrant or a valid exception, the defense can challenge their actions. The defense can also challenge a defective warrant. To win, the defense must show that the search more likely than not violated constitutional rights. This standard is called a preponderance of the evidence. If the judge grants the motion, the prosecution may struggle to continue the case. In many cases, the excluded evidence forms the basis of the charges.

Requests to dismiss charges on legal grounds

A motion to dismiss asks the judge to remove one or more charges or dismiss the entire case. The defense may file this motion when the evidence is too weak or the alleged conduct does not qualify as a crime. In felony cases, defendants can file a Penal Code 995 motion after a preliminary hearing. They may argue that the judge lacked probable cause or that the commitment was unlawful. A different judge usually hears this motion. This gives the case another review. If the judge grants the motion, the charges get dismissed. However, the prosecutor may appeal, refile the charges, or continue with any remaining counts. If the court dismisses every charge, it must refund the defendant’s bail within 15 days unless the prosecution refiles.

How testimony and legal arguments shape the ruling

At a suppression hearing, the officer who conducted the search usually testifies. Both sides can question the officer before presenting their legal arguments. The judge then reviews the testimony and arguments. The judge decides whether the search violated the defendant’s rights. No jury attends these hearings. The judge alone decides whether witnesses seem credible and whether the court can use certain evidence at trial.

Felony Preliminary Hearings and the Next Court Dates

A felony preliminary hearing carries more weight than a routine pretrial conference. A pretrial conference usually covers settlement talks and scheduling. A preliminary hearing, however, involves live testimony. Witnesses testify under oath, and the judge decides whether probable cause exists.

In some cases, a defendant can waive this hearing by pleading guilty or giving up the right. The defendant must have legal representation or waive that right in open court. After the waiver, the prosecution must file the Information within 15 days.

At this stage, the judge has a limited role. The judge only decides whether enough evidence exists for the case to move forward. The judge does not decide whether the defendant is guilty.

If the judge finds probable cause, the court holds the defendant to answer. The prosecution then files an Information. The defendant must attend a second arraignment based on those charges.

After that, the trial deadline begins. The prosecution must start the trial within 60 days of the arraignment on the Information. However, the defendant can waive this deadline. A general waiver stops the clock until the defendant withdraws it. If the defendant refuses to waive the deadline, the prosecution must follow the schedule. The court may set more pretrial dates. These hearings give both sides time to reach a deal or prepare for trial.

Conclusion

A California pretrial hearing involves much more than setting court dates. Discovery, settlement talks, suppression motions, and preliminary hearings can all affect your case. These steps may lead to a dismissal, a plea deal, or a trial. The decisions you make during this stage can shape the outcome before a jury hears the evidence. Preparation is important at every step. Review police reports and make sure you understand what a plea offer means for your record and rights. Under these circumstances, consulting with an experienced defense attorney can help you understand your options. An attorney can also explain your rights and help you prepare a strong defense.

RELATED ARTICLE:

Theft Attorney - Call 213-932-8922
 (Click to Enlarge)

Need an Attorney? CALL NOW: 213-932-8922

Yuliya Kelmansky is an Expert Attorney who has over 10 years of practice defending a variety of cases.

Reputation is Everything

› ‹
  • five-star reviewVery well, spoken, organized, reaches deep into the facts, sensitive to a clients needs and is not shaken by her opposition. Knows how to stand up for her client. I would go to battle with her any day as co-counsel.- Charles F.

  • five-star reviewI had a case where a friend accused me of things I did not do. The accusations were untrue but I was charged. Within a couple weeks my case was dropped. Very thankful to Yuliya! Recommend.- Alexander M.

  • five-star reviewJulia is a great and attentive attorney. We needed to expunge my husband’s DUI case that took place 15 years ago and Julia helped us to get it done within no time. Highly recommend her services to anyone who is looking for a criminal law attorney!- Karina S.

  • five-star reviewI’m so grateful for the services that were provided by Yuliya. Her experience, kindness, and thoroughness during this difficult time went above and beyond. Yuliya was there for every court date and explained to me every step. I highly recommend her.- Alexandr S.

Free Consultation

    Contact Us Form