Involuntary Intoxication Defense in California
Criminal law provides a variety of sanctions for offenses that vary depending on the circumstances. Common criminal law defenses, such as insanity, infancy, and intoxication, are predicated on the defendant’s inability to be held legally accountable. Whether these defenses apply depends on the specific facts of the case and the defendant’s mental state at the time of the alleged offense.
Intoxication in Criminal Cases
Intoxication can sometimes be a viable defense when accused of certain crimes. Although intoxication does not automatically excuse criminal conduct, alcohol and drugs can affect a person’s ability to form the intent required for certain crimes.
Criminal defendants can utilize intoxication as a defense, arguing that they were unaware of the consequences of their acts or what they were doing because of their intoxication. Whether intoxication can be used as a defense depends on several factors, including whether the intoxication was voluntary or involuntary and the level of intent required for the charged offense. California recognizes voluntary and involuntary intoxication defenses, but only allows the defense to be raised in cases of involuntary intoxication.
Voluntary Intoxication Defense
When the accused intentionally ingests alcohol or drugs, knowing it would impair their judgment, it is voluntary intoxication. Only specific purpose crimes, or crimes where the perpetrator acts with the intent to commit a crime, such as murder under Penal Code 187 PC, are eligible for this legal defense.
Because you recognize the risk of having impaired judgment when you intentionally consume an intoxicating substance, voluntary intoxication as a defense becomes a bit more difficult.
California Criminal Jury Instructions 3426 stipulate that juries may only consider voluntary intoxication in situations where the prosecution must establish a defendant’s “specific purpose” to commit a crime, and the intoxication raises “reasonable suspicion” about that intent.
It would be best first to acknowledge that you were not sober when you committed the offense to claim voluntary intoxication as a defense. After that, prove that your behavior deviated from what it would have been if you were sober due to the intoxication. Examples of crimes with a particular intent include forgery, murder, and theft, where a defendant must consciously act to take another person’s property.
Involuntary Intoxication Defense
The use of alcohol, drugs, or other intoxicating substances without consent brought on through coercion or manipulation is known as involuntary intoxication. In many counties, involuntary intoxication is a legal defense against criminal charges. In these jurisdictions, a defendant may introduce proof of his intoxication to demonstrate that he committed the crime. At the same time, he is unaware of the wrongness of his actions and should not be held.
Most jurisdictions would not accept an involuntary intoxication defense if a defendant believed they were ingesting one illicit drug, like weed, but was, in reality, consuming another. Furthermore, the California court system does not allow the defense of involuntary intoxication to be invoked just because someone is a drunk, even though alcoholics might contend that their addiction forces them to drink.
According to common law, a person can be involuntarily inebriated in four ways.
- Intoxication can be caused through coercion or compulsion.
- A medical condition might pathologically bring about toxicity.
- Intoxication might occur due to taking a drug prescribed by a doctor.
- Intoxication may occur due to an honest error or misjudgment of the intoxicating effects of a drug, like accidentally taking a pain pill that causes drowsiness.
For example, you have an assault with dangerous weapon charge, after attacking someone in a mall with a metal rod.
You believe you hallucinated at the time because someone forced you to take a pill earlier. While in detention, a blood test discovered traces of ecstasy in your blood, which you deny taking. You can claim involuntary intoxication since you thought it was only a multivitamin, as told by your intoxicator, but mistakenly took a substance known to produce hallucinations and aggression.
Related Articles:
What Laws Does California Enact to Help Prevent Date Rape?
What Are The Consequences of Drugging Someone for Sexual Intercourse?
What Is An ‘Affirmative Defense’ In Criminal Law?
Need Legal Help?
If you’re facing accusations, especially if you believe someone else is to blame, it’s vital to understand your legal defense alternatives. Involuntary intoxication does occur, whether as a joke or for evil motives, and it can endanger you and others.
Need an Attorney? CALL NOW: 213-932-8922
Yuliya Kelmansky is an Expert Attorney who has over 10 years of practice defending a variety of cases.
